Independently-owned-and-operated coffee shops are holding their own against the national chains by creating a sense of local identity

For the majority of Americans, the day hasn’t officially begun until a cup or two of coffee jolts us awake. With millions of people stopping on the way to work to grab a morning brew or partaking of an afternoon caffeine fix, this clearly creates demand. One might think this in turn would lead to brutal competition between national chains like Starbucks and Dunkin’ Donuts and independent coffee shops and local chains.
But it appears as if that’s not the case.

In Delaware, at least, the local players seem to be keeping their customers coming in day after day, essentially unaffected by large chains. They’re not simply existing; they’re thriving, thanks to creative strategies and a sense of community that transcend the standard sugary jolt of Joe.

Take Brewed Awakenings, for example. During a recent chilly November afternoon, the modest, warmly-lit space on Newark’s Main Street is a sanctuary from the cold. Local art hangs from the walls, a student quietly works on homework by a window, and a cluster of young people are engaged in conversation, seated at tables beneath a floor-length shelf of old books.

Surveying the room, owner J.D. Willetts doesn’t appear concerned about the future of local coffee shops. In fact, he smiles and nods in the direction of the group of people hanging out, as if their presence holds an answer. And in a way, it does.

“They work here, but they’re not on the clock—they’re just here to hang out,” he says. “And I don’t know how true that is at the big chains. But here, we’re a family.”

Drip Café helps create a sense of hometown pride, say owner Greg Vogeley. (Photo courtesy of Drip Café)

Drip Café helps create a sense of hometown pride, say owner Greg Vogeley. (Photo courtesy of Drip Café)

Willetts ticks off examples of the sense of community Brewed Awakenings enjoys: one customer fixes the shop’s internet for free; another does artwork; someone else takes care of accounting in exchange for a few lattes on the house.

Newark resident Zac Bartosh, who frequents independent coffee shops, agrees that they’re a personal experience, and what keeps him coming back to places like Brewed Awakenings is the welcoming environment. “The advantage of locally-owned coffee shops is much more than just the coffee. The employees know you by name, and have a genuine interest in you as a person,” Bartosh says.

A passion for people

When Willetts, who worked as a psychologist for 25 years, purchased the coffee shop this past summer, he knew he personally wouldn’t be making any profit from Brewed Awakenings. He brought the shop under his nonprofit Abide Foundation, and from the beginning he has worked fulltime as a volunteer. He also immediately implemented the Community Cup, which is a pay-it-forward option—customers can donate any amount of money toward a future customer’s beverage or meal.

To Ben Cordova, general manager at LOMA Coffee on Market Street in Wilmington, such above-and-beyond methods fall under the heading “passion for people.” Cordova refers to local coffee shops as a “third space” to relax between home and work.

In fact, when Hockessin’s Sycamore Hill Church opened LOMA five years ago, the goal was strictly to serve a need in the community by creating a shared space. He says that’s one reason LOMA is still flourishing, with growing numbers each year.

“These are environments to come to, have a nice beverage and sandwich, and chat,” says Cordova. “It’s about bringing people together to commune with them. They’re consuming a product, yes, and we’re preparing a product, but together we’re one unit, aiming to encourage and uplift each other.”

Greg Vogeley, owner of Drip Café in Hockessin, has noticed that the community desperately wants a sense of local pride. Like Willetts, who celebrates increased involvement, Vogeley wants to encourage the community’s sense of ownership.
“People really want to have their hometown coffee shop,” Vogeley says. “They still want that to be theirs, to call it ‘mine.’”

Brew HaHa! owner Alisa Morkides stands with the other local shops. Even though she has opened nine New Castle County locations during her 20 years in the business, she emphasizes the importance of tailoring each one to its community. She views Brew HaHa! as a “boutique collection,” and says it will always be a Delaware thing.

“The way we succeed is through local identity,” says Morkides. “It is challenging, because obviously a big chain has so many more economic advantages than we do. But here, it’s all about the people.”

Room for both?

And more and more, “the people” are opting for local, giving the major chains a run for their money, Morkides says. Third wave coffee (a movement focusing on producing high-quality, artisanal coffee) has been on the rise over the last several years, Cordova notes, which has made a huge dent in the market share.

And according to these area shopkeepers, not only are big players not comparable to their cafes, but they’ve never even been a challenge.

During a recent chilly November afternoon, the modest, warmly-lit space on Newark’s Brewed Awakenings on Main Street is a sanctuary from the cold. (Photo by Krista Connor)

During a recent chilly November afternoon,
the modest, warmly-lit space on Newark’s Brewed Awakenings on Main Street is a sanctuary from the cold. (Photo courtesy of Brewed Awakenings)

“They’re two completely different animals, Starbucks and the local shop,” says Cordova. “I shop at Costco, but I also love shopping at my local neighborhood store. That’s the difference, and there’s room for both. Two Starbucks have opened in the city now, and our business has not been affected.”

Willetts and Vogeley also have seen major chains open near their shops, and they share the same opinion—they’re simply no competition. Willetts says the only thing they have in common is coffee, and from there they diverge.

“If you want to make a lot of money, get a Starbucks. If you want to make a lot of friends, have a coffee shop,” Willetts says.

Somewhat surprisingly, Willetts and Cordova not only respect the business models of chains like Starbucks, but compliment them. Cordova argues that Starbucks paved the way for the third-wave independent coffee bar scene, and he is grateful.

In fact, Willetts’ son is “working for the big boys” as a Starbucks manager. “He’ll do more business in a week than I’ll do in a month or two, and that’s okay,” says Willetts.

What’s more, Willetts owns stock in Starbucks, not because he’s “rah-rah Starbucks,” but simply because the stock does well. “To me, that’s not inconsistent at all, because I don’t see them as competition—they’re selling a different product,” he says.

“I think people know where they fit in by now,” Drip Café’s Vogeley says. “If you’re doing your job right as a small business owner, it doesn’t matter what others are doing.”

Willetts says Brewed Awakenings is frequently complimented on its low prices and the “little extra things” that baristas do, like transferring coffee to to-go cups and topping them off. These touches say, “Hey, you’re important,” Willetts says. “I want to keep the quality as high as I can, the cost as low as I can, and have the friendliest people employed.”

Aside from good quality coffee, these shops feature fresh, local, handcrafted food, such as Drip Café’s pancakes and Brewed Awakenings’ customizable salads. And you just don’t get that at big chains, where food is typically pre-packaged, Willetts says.

Expansion and what’s brewing

The consensus seems to be that local shops are on the rise. Morkides is confident that even more independent coffee shops and roasters – like her Brandywine Coffee Roasters, which opened at the Trolley Square Brew HaHa! location in June – will be on the scene in the future. She’s excited about the expansion of the Greenville Brew HaHa!, which will be open by spring or early summer 2016. The current location will move to a larger space in the same shopping center, Powder Mill Square. The new 3,000-square-foot shop will feature all coffee-brewing methods, have later hours, and serve alcohol.

Vogeley says Drip Café is wrapping things up for the season with its successful food truck, The Brunch Box, but look for it to be on the streets again in March.

LOMA’s Cordova is opening his own coffee bar at 10th and Market streets in the Citizens Bank Building lobby. Called Coffee Mode, it’ll open between Christmas and January, and will feature “over-the-top, freshly prepared coffee” with a high-end New York-style feel. Cordova will continue managing LOMA as well.

Willetts says he’s open for a Brewed Awakenings’ expansion, but there is nothing planned right now. In the meantime, the shop is hosting Thursday night open mics each week until 10 p.m. A board game night also is in the works.
Brewed Awakenings will be closed for a week between Christmas and New Year’s Day to get freshly-painted walls, and customers and staff are volunteering their time alongside Willetts to help out, while enjoying some free coffee.

“It’ll be a fun time,” says Willetts. “Just people who care about the shop doing stuff together.” Which is the essence of local coffee shops.